Law 14,754 · Tax Regimes

One offshore or two? When combining regimes can make sense

Criteria for assessing whether opaque and transparent structures should coexist, and the path the law provides for reorganizing without triggering tax.

Since Law No. 14,754/2023, anyone who holds a company abroad must define the tax regime that applies in Brazil: the opaque regime, which is the default, or the transparent regime, which requires an express election by the investor. If no election is made, the opaque regime is deemed chosen.

In practice, neither regime is more efficient in every situation. Each one works best for a certain asset profile, and diversified portfolios tend to combine assets with very different characteristics. Because the election, or non-election, of the transparent regime is irrevocable for as long as the individual holds that entity, the decision cannot be adjusted once the portfolio profile changes within the same structure.

Hence the question that keeps coming up in our conversations: does it make sense to keep two structures, one under each regime? It can, and the law provides a path for it. In this article, we explain how each regime works, when separation tends to pay off, how to identify the right moment to decide and how the reorganization is carried out without triggering tax.

How each regime works

Under the opaque regime, the company is recognized as an entity separate from the individual. The profit shown in the financial statements on December 31 is taxed annually at 15%, regardless of distribution and regardless of whether the assets have been sold. Once taxed, the profit can be distributed to the shareholder without further tax, which requires a separate record of the balance of profits already taxed.

Under the transparent regime, the company is disregarded for Brazilian tax purposes. The assets are reported and taxed as if they were held directly by the individual, each according to its nature, and tax is due only on what is actually realized.

The table below summarizes the differences that weigh most in the decision.

Opaque regimeTransparent regime
Tax baseProfit shown in the balance sheetIncome realized by each asset
Unrealized gainsTaxed based on the December 31 balance sheetTaxed only upon realization
Deduction of expensesAllowedNot allowed
Offset of lossesAmong the assets of the same entityAmong the assets of the individual and of transparent companies, and against the profit of opaque structures
Tax paid abroadCreditable, regardless of the countryOnly with a treaty or reciprocity, capped at 15%
Exchange variation on capitalNot part of the tax calculationPart of the tax calculation
Real estate incomePart of the profit, with 15% tax only in the annual returnMonthly tax (carnê-leão) and capital gains, paid the following month
Individual income tax returnShareholding in the companyOpen portfolio, asset by asset
Best suited forActive management, broad portfolio, many transactionsLong-term holding, lean portfolio, tax exit

Succession, it is worth noting, is the same under both. In either regime, transfer happens through the company’s shares, with no exposure to the U.S. estate tax. The difference between opaque and transparent is purely a tax matter.

The logic of two structures

When the portfolio combines assets with opposite profiles, separation becomes an alternative worth considering. Assets held for the very long term, with no intention of selling, commonly sit in transparent structures, where unrealized gains are not taxed. Assets with frequent turnover, which generate deductible expenses and bear taxes above 15%, remain in the opaque structure.

Classification is made per entity, independently, even within the same corporate chain. In other words, an opaque entity may hold a transparent entity and vice versa.

There is, however, one point of care when combining the two (opaque and transparent) in the same chain. If a transparent subsidiary distributes earnings to an opaque one, that amount must be excluded from the investor company’s profit base, precisely to avoid taxing the same result twice. This tends to be one of the complexities faced by investors who already have this kind of structure.

The interim balance sheet as a decision tool

The choice between one or two structures is usually treated as a conceptual discussion, when in fact it should also be based on accounting figures.

For our advisory clients, we prepare an interim balance sheet with the results of the first three quarters. With it, the investor knows, while the year is still running, the structure’s accumulated profit and the order of magnitude of the tax that will apply to the December 31 position.

This early view gives the investor direct input on the tax impact the structure will have on the individual income tax return. When the accumulated profit is mostly unrealized, coming from assets the investor has no intention of selling, it becomes clear that the 15% rate is being paid in advance on a gain that may only materialize ten or twenty years from now, or never materialize for the investor at all, because it will be passed on as inheritance.

An order-of-magnitude illustration. A US$ 3 million portfolio held in an opaque structure, with 12% unrealized appreciation in the year, accumulates around US$ 360 thousand of gains not yet realized. The 15% tax on that amount is roughly US$ 54 thousand, paid on a gain the investor does not intend to realize.

The additional cost of keeping a second structure over the same period is around US$ 3 thousand.

The effect, importantly, is not an exemption but a deferral. Even so, deferral has significant economic value over the years and may become permanent when the wealth is destined for succession.

Above all, by running the balance sheet during the year, there is still time to act. A reorganization completed before year-end translates into tax savings in the current year.

How to assess the decision

With the interim balance sheet in hand, we recommend asking a few initial questions:

  • What share of the profit accumulated in the year comes from unrealized gains on assets with no planned sale?
  • What is the estimated tax on that share on December 31, and is the same tax likely to recur in the coming years?
  • Is there a horizon of tax exit from Brazil, change of residence or liquidity event that would change the picture in the coming years?

In most of the cases we follow, the answer depends less on the size of the wealth and more on the composition of the portfolio. Portfolios truly split between a trading portion and a long-term portion, or those held exclusively for the long term, are the ones that benefit most from the second structure, and that benefit repeats every year.

How to carry out the reorganization without triggering tax

A common reading is that changing regimes would require winding up the existing company and incorporating a new one, with all the costs and tax effects of a liquidation. Fortunately, that is not the only path.

Law No. 14,754/2023 and Normative Instruction RFB No. 2,180/2024 allow the contribution of assets and rights from an opaque controlled company to the capital of a transparent entity to be made at book value, with no need for a market valuation. The Q&A published by the Brazilian Federal Revenue Service on both rules is explicit about the distinction between the two directions of the transaction.

Q&A on Law No. 14,754/2023 and Normative Instruction RFB No. 2,180/2024, Question 43. The transfer of assets and rights from a transparent entity to a controlled company subject to annual taxation of profits “must be made at market value”, with tax on the difference between that value and cost.

The capital contribution to a transparent entity by an opaque controlled company, on the other hand, “may be made at book value”.

In practice, the reorganization goes through four steps.

Incorporation of the new company as a subsidiary of the existing offshore, keeping the funds within the corporate chain.

Transfer of the selected assets from the opaque structure to the subsidiary, at book value.

Calculation of the proportion of each asset transferred, to determine the amount in dollars and in reais that leaves the share capital line in the tax return and becomes the cost of the new entity.

Election of the transparent regime for the new entity when filing the income tax return.

The second and third steps require the most attention. The acquisition cost must be segregated asset by asset, in proportion to each one’s book value in the balance sheet, with the conversion into reais following the same criterion. Particular care is needed here, as these are the moments when errors in the tax return tend to occur. In the income tax return, the lines are adjusted, but the total remains the same, both in dollars and in reais.

The path that triggers tax

There is a seemingly simpler alternative that produces a very different tax result: withdrawing the funds from the opaque offshore, bringing them to the individual and then contributing them to a new transparent structure.

Withdrawing funds from the structure to the individual realizes the exchange variation between the average dollar cost of the share capital and the exchange rate on the withdrawal date. In structures set up some years ago, this difference is usually significant, and tax applies even if the investor does not bring the money to Brazil and intends to put exactly the same amount into another company on the same day.

The internal reorganization, from controlled company to subsidiary, does not produce this effect, because the funds do not pass through the individual. It is the difference between a neutral transaction and one taxed on a purely currency gain.

How much the second structure costs

Each company has its own set of mandatory costs. There is no dilution between them. Below is a summary of costs; for more detail, see the article Offshore Companies: Advantages, Costs and When to Set One Up.

ItemOne structureTwo structures
BVI registered agentUS$ 850US$ 1,700
BVI government annual feeUS$ 550US$ 1,100
AccountingFrom US$ 1,500From US$ 3,000
Approximate totalAround US$ 3 thousandAround US$ 6 thousand

Note that the transparent structure does not eliminate accounting work. Even though no profit is calculated for Brazilian purposes, the company keeps its local obligations, such as the Financial Annual Return in the BVI, and the individual who files the DCBE (Brazilian Capital Abroad declaration) needs accounting information for it.

The final math is straightforward: does the tax no longer paid in advance on unrealized gains exceed the roughly US$ 3 thousand in additional annual costs? In portfolios with significant appreciation, the difference usually shows up in the very first year.

Talk to our team. The decision between one or two structures is specific to each portfolio and each family, and it gains a lot when it stops being conceptual and becomes based on numbers.

We prepare interim balance sheets and advisory work to support exactly this kind of decision, measuring the profit accumulated in the year, estimating the tax due on December 31 and analyzing the reorganization alternatives before year-end.

If you have a structure abroad and want to understand how much tax it will generate this year, talk to us. There is still time to assess it.

Talk to 4Tax

We take care of our clients’ structures, from planning to the design and implementation of the right structure for each family, monitoring obligations in Brazil and in each jurisdiction throughout the whole international investment journey.

Invest abroad and count on us to support you through the whole process of planning, structuring and annual follow-up of your wealth abroad. Reach us on WhatsApp (+55 11 4306-9841) or write to [email protected].

Chat on WhatsApp Leave a message
Please note: the amounts, deadlines and costs indicated in this article are reference estimates and vary according to the jurisdiction, the asset profile and the providers involved. This content is for information purposes only and does not constitute legal or tax advice. Rules and rates may be changed by the competent authorities. We recommend consulting our team or your advisors for an analysis of your specific case.

Want to know how much tax your structure will generate this year?

We prepare your structure’s interim balance sheet and analyze the reorganization alternatives before year-end.

Talk to a specialist